One of the most common forms of training for plant operators worldwide is presented by manufacturers of civil engineering plant. This form of training occurs when new plant is purchased, the manufacturer usually assembles the equipment, sets-up and calibrates the equipment and provides limited training for the designated operator that entails a demonstration of the new plant.
For the purpose of this comparison this form of “sales related training” was considered limited to the plant and was therefore not considered. Qualifications that offered a holistic approach for entry level plant operators from the following countries were evaluated as the approach and purpose compared closely:
- Australia.
- United Kingdom.
- New Zealand.
No equivalent qualifications were found to be offered by African countries as illustrated by the following searches:
- Technical, Entrepreneurial and Vocational Education and Training Authority (TEVETA) of Malawi.
- Vocational Education and Training Authority (VETA) of Zambia.
- Botswana Training Authority (BOTA) of Botswana.
Australia:
Certificate II in Civil Construction (Plant Operations) BCC30603 is of 24 month duration. All fifteen (15) of the following core competency units and four (4) elective competency units must be achieved for this qualification:
- BCCCM1001B: Follow OH and S policies and procedures.
- BCCCM1002B: Conduct workplace communication.
- BCCCM1003B: Plan and organise work.
- BCCCM1004B: Carry out measurements and calculations.
- BCCCM1005B: Handle construction materials and safely dispose of non-toxic materials.
- BCCCM2001B: Use civil construction hand and power tools.
- BCCCM2002B: Use small plant and equipment.
- BCCCM2003B: Read and interpret plans and specifications.
- BCCCM2004B: Drain and dewater site.
- BCCCM2005B: Carry out manual excavation.
- BCCCM2007B: Spread and compact materials manually.
- BCCCM2008B: Carry out basic leveling.
- BCCCM2013B: Control traffic with a stop-slow bat.
- BCCCM2014B: Identify, locate and protect underground services.
- BCCCM2006B: Support plant operations.
Group A; Elective; Unit; Title:
- BCCPO3001B: Conduct backhoe/loader operations.
- BCCPO3002B: Conduct dozer operations.
- BCCPO3003B: Conduct excavator operations.
- BCCPO3004B: Conduct wheeled front end loader operations.
- BCCPO3005B: Conduct tracked front end loader operations.
- BCCPO3006B: Conduct grader operations.
- BCCPO3007B: Conduct scraper operations.
- BCCPO3008B: Conduct skid steer loader operations.
- BCCPO3009B: Conduct pipe layer operations.
Group B; Elective; Unit; Title:
- BCCPO3010B: Conduct integrated tool carrier operations.
- BCCPO3011B: Conduct tractor operations.
- BCCPO3012B: Conduct tip truck operations.
- BCCPO3013B: Conduct roller operations.
- BCCPO3014B: Conduct water cart operations.
- BCCPO3015B: Conduct continuous bucket trencher operations.
- BCCPO3016B: Conduct dump truck operations.
- BCCPO3017B: Conduct self propelled compactor operations.
- BCCPO3018B: Conduct paver operations.
- BCCPO3019B: Conduct stabiliser operations.
A comparison of the duration of formal study for these compared qualifications varies with the Australian certificate taking 2 years to achieve. This is because the licensing requirements are included for the achievement of the qualification, while this requirement is not part of the South African equivalent.
The above elective units (Groups A and B) compare closely with the electives of the South African qualification. While the units for “pipe layer”, “tool carrier” and “stabilizer” are included here these plant do not feature in the South African qualification. The remaining plant compare directly in terms of the level, outcomes, credit value and assessment.
A comparison of the core unit standards suggest that the following South African unit standards cover similar learning areas to that of the Australian unit standards indicated above:
- Demonstrate an understanding of Occupational Health, Safety and Environmental Legislations.
- Describe the construction industry composition its work procurement systems and communication techniques.
- Establish and prepare a work area.
- Demonstrate an understanding of earthworks.
- Apply regulatory requirements in plant operations.
- Demonstrate knowledge of civil construction works.
United Kingdom:
The National Vocational Qualification in Plant Operations, Level 2 (100/5587/3) provides for plant operations that cover a vast range of plant resources and activities which include:
- Lifting plant or machines.
- Transferring plant or machines.
- Extracting plant or machines.
- Excavating plant or machines.
- Construction and formation plant or machines.
- Receiving or transporting plant or machines.
- Accessing plant or machines.
- Laying or distributing plant or machines.
- Compacting plant or machines.
- Processing plant or machines.
The following three mandatory units form the core component of this qualification:
- R/102/3275: Conform to general workplace safety.
- Y/102/3276: Conform to efficient work practices.
- M/103/3747: Prepare plant or machinery for operational performance.
The following units represent the elective component of the qualification:
- T/103/3748: Operate plant or machinery to lift and transfer loads.
- A/103/3749: Operate plant or machinery to extract.
- M/103/3750: Operate plant or machinery to excavate.
- T/103/3751: Operate plant or machinery to construct and form.
- A/103/3752: Operate plant or machinery to receive and transport loads.
- F/103/3753: Operate plant or machinery for accessing.
- J/103/3754: Operate plant or machinery to lay and distribute.
- L/103/3755: Operate plant or machinery to compact.
- R/103/3756: Operate plant or machinery to process.
- R/103/3711: Direct and guide the movement of plant or machinery.
- K/103/3715: Arrange and secure loads.
- Y/103/3757: Operate road rail plant.
- D/103/3758: Operate ancillary equipment.
Additional Units (not compulsory):
- D/102/3277: Move and handle resources.
- M/103/3716: Operate specialised powered tools and equipment.
- T/103/3717: Set out secondary dimensional work control.
- A/103/3721: Slinging and signalling the movement of loads.
- H/103/3759: Plant operations from a barge.
- Y/103/3760: Erect and dismantle plant (Cranes and Rigs).
The learning areas covered by all three core unit standards identified above are also catered for in the following South African core unit standards:
- Demonstrate an understanding of Occupational Health, Safety and Environmental Legislations.
- Apply productivity principles on a construction site.
- Apply quality principles on a construction site.
- Demonstrate a basic understanding of the mechanics of plant.
The plant catered for here has not been named in the titles of the elective units but has been clustered in terms of their functions. This approach differs from the South African qualification that clusters the plant into three categories namely, transport, earthmoving and ancillary and refers to the plant under consideration in the unit standard titles. Despite this difference in approach the qualifying learners will be able to operate the same type of plant except for cranes.
New Zealand:
The National Certificate in Civil Plant Operation (Bulk Earthmoving), Level 3, 80 Credits has been designed for entry level plant operators. This qualification will be awarded to people who have met the requirements of the compulsory and elective sections.
All the standards listed below are required:
- Inspect civil construction plant and equipment (6436), Level 4, 5 credits.
- Demonstrate knowledge of soil properties for earthworks (20477), Level 2, 3 credits.
- Demonstrate knowledge of earthworks i.r.o. the environment (20616), Level 2, 4 credits.
- Demonstrate knowledge of bulk earthmoving (20624), Level 2, 2 credits.
- Apply safe work practices in the workplace (17593), Level 2, 4 credits.
A minimum of 62 credits, including a minimum of 3 standards is required from Elective Set A or a combination of Elective Set B.
Elective Set A:
- Operate a wheeled loader on civil construction sites (17309), Level 3, 20 credits.
- Operate a hydraulic excavator on civil construction sites (17310), Level 3, 25 credits.
- Operate a motor grader for earthworks (17311), Level 3, 30 credits.
- Operate a motor scraper on civil construction sites (17314), Level 3, 20 credits.
- Operate a self-propelled roller on civil construction sites (17315), Level 3, 20 credits.
- Operate a bulldozer on civil construction sites, (17316), Level 3, 20 credits.
- Operate an articulated dump truck on civil construction sites (17317), Level 3, 20 credits.
- Operate a rigid dump truck for bulk earthmoving (20625), Level 3, 12 credits.
- Operate a hydraulic face shovel (20626), Level 3, 15 credits.
- Operate a water cart for earthworks (20628), Level 3, 12 credits.
Elective Set B:
- Describe the prevention of immobilisation and the recovery of immobilised machines (20627), Level 2, 2 credits.
- Manage first aid in emergency situations (6400), Level 3, 2 credits.
- Provide first aid (6401), Level 2, 1 credit.
- Provide resuscitation level 2 (6402), Level 1, 1 credit.
- Demonstrate knowledge and skills for driving on a road for endorsement W (wheels) (16701), Level 3, 3 credits.
- Demonstrate knowledge and skills for driving on a road for endorsement R (rollers) (16702), Level 3, 3 credits.
- Demonstrate knowledge and skills for driving on a road for endorsement T (tracks) (16703), Level 3, 3 credits.
The learning areas covered by four of the five core unit standards identified above are also catered for in the following South African core unit standards:
- Demonstrate a basic understanding of earthworks.
- Demonstrate an understanding and implement environmental initiatives on a construction activity.
- Demonstrate an understanding of Occupational Health, Safety and Environmental Legislations.
- Demonstrate knowledge of civil construction works.
The learning area covered by the remaining core unit on “inspecting plant” is catered for in all the elective unit standards in relation to each type of plant rather than a separate unit standard for this competency.
The South African qualification offers a wider range of plant (23) in the elective component compared to this New Zealand qualification (10). The three “first aid” units of elective set B share common learning areas with the following core unit standards of the National Certificate in Plant Operations, Level 2:
- Perform basic fire fighting.
- Provide risk-based primary emergency care/first aid in the workplace.
Conclusion:
All the compared qualifications serve the same purpose of preparing qualifying learners to acquire entry level knowledge and skills to be able to operate selected plant in various contexts. The core unit standards of these qualifications reflect similarities pertaining to “safety”, “first-aid”, “earthworks and civil construction works” and “environmental issues”. The scope of the core component of the South African qualification exceeds its counterparts as it prepares the learner for the workplace beyond the operation of plant to include other important competencies to ensure success.
The approach to the clustering of the elective units for each type of plant differ, however, all the common plant used is catered for in these qualifications. The Australian qualification reflects the closest similarity as it provides for operating nineteen of the twenty three plant catered for in the South African equivalent.
|
Reviews
There are no reviews yet.